| Platinum | Bob's Pizza & Amante's Italian Cuisine |
| Gold | Brusco's Italian Restaurant and Pizza |
| Silver | Patrizias of NYC, Deerfield Beach |
| Bronze | Luigi di Roma Italian Ristorante |
| Bronze | Umberto's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Amante's Italian Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Streat Arts Cafe |
| Top Pick | Thick & Thin Pizza |